Demon Daily

Describing the Flaw

Demon Team

Demon Team

Nov 6, 2026

Recognizing that an argument is flawed is different from explaining why.

One points you in the right direction. The other points you to the right answer.

You don’t need to memorize a long list of flaws to develop that skill. You need a well-placed question or concrete objection.

Put the Mayor's Argument to the Test

Consider the following argument:

Mayor: Our city will experience a large economic burst within the next month. Every large burst in the city's economy has come in the month after I announced sales tax cuts, and I just announced more sales tax cuts this afternoon.

Restate the argument. 

Conclusion: The city’s economy will experience a large burst within the next month.

Evidence: Every previous burst came in the month after the mayor announced sales tax cuts. And the mayor just announced another round of cuts.

What questions or objections do you have? 

Here’s one:

How many times has the mayor announced sales tax cuts and an economic burst didn’t follow?

Imagine the mayor has announced sales tax cuts every month for the past ten years. But during that time, the city experienced just one large economic burst.

The mayor's evidence would still be true. Every economic burst occurred after an announcement of sales tax cuts.

But would another announcement give us good reason to expect another burst?

Nope.

The mayor established that economic bursts have followed tax-cut announcements in the past. But not that tax-cut announcements reliably lead to economic bursts.

It’s like a weather forecaster who predicts rain every day. Every rainstorm followed a rain prediction, but the prediction is worthless because it happens no matter what.

We've identified a specific objection by identifying a situation where the mayor's evidence is true but the conclusion remains unsupported. That’s the key. 

You Don’t Need a Name for Every Flaw

You could slap a label on the mayor’s mistake. But you don’t need to. 

The question did the work. It explains, in plain English, exactly why the evidence doesn’t prove the conclusion.

That’s what describing a flaw means. Not naming a category, but putting your finger on the specific thing the author didn’t prove. A concrete question or example is usually the best way to do it.

Turn Your Objection Into a Prediction

Here’s the actual LSAT question about the mayor’s argument: 

Which one of the following arguments exhibits a pattern of reasoning most similar to that exhibited by the mayor’s argument? 

It never says the argument is flawed. But if you attacked the argument before reading the question, you already know what you’re looking for.

Your objection becomes the test. For each answer, ask whether the same question would hurt it.

Consider this answer choice:

Each time our dishwasher has overflowed, it was minutes after we put Sparkle dish detergent inside. We accidentally put Sparkle dish detergent inside our dishwasher, which means it will overflow within the next few minutes.

We can raise the same objection we raised against the mayor.

How many times have they used Sparkle dish detergent without the dishwasher overflowing?

Maybe this household has run Sparkle in every load for years and the dishwasher has overflowed once. Same question, same damage.

Just as the mayor's tax-cut announcements don't necessarily predict economic bursts, using Sparkle detergent doesn't necessarily predict an overflow.

The subject is different, but the reasoning is the same. That's why this is the correct answer.

Similar Topics Don’t Mean Similar Reasoning

Another answer choice discusses interest rates and home listings:

Interest rates were cut in half today, so hundreds of homes will be listed over the next 24 hours. Whenever interest rates are cut in half, hundreds of homes are listed on the market within one day.

On the surface, this looks like the mayor’s argument. There’s a recent event, an economic topic, and a prediction. 

Now ask the same question. How many times have interest rates been cut in half without hundreds of homes being listed?

The evidence says that whenever rates are cut in half, hundreds of homes get listed. That’s exactly the evidence the mayor didn’t have. He didn’t say “Whenever I announce tax cuts, there’s an economic burst.”

You can’t make the same objection to this argument, so it isn’t parallel.

Understanding the precise problem with the mayor's reasoning allows us to distinguish the two.

It’s Okay if Your Description Is Messy at First

If you can spot that something’s off but struggle to put it into words, that’s normal. Everyone starts with muddled descriptions. The effort of forming your objection makes it sharper. 

Over time, you’ll see the same kinds of arguments again and again. You’ll read a correlation and expect a causal conclusion before the author gets there, and you’ll have two or three reasons it fails in your mind.

The LSAT is a skills test, and skills improve with practice. 

Put It Into Practice

On your next Logical Reasoning question, focus on understanding the argument before looking at the question.

Identify the conclusion and the evidence supporting it. Then ask yourself: Could the evidence be true while the conclusion is false?

If so, explain why. Come up with a concrete counterexample or a question that exposes the gap in the reasoning.

Don't settle for knowing an argument is flawed. Explain exactly why.

 

Questions? ​ daily@lsatdemon.com

Start studying: https://lsatdemon.com

Scholarship Estimator: https://lsatdemon.com/scholarships

More LSAT Demon resources: https://linktr.ee/lsatdemon